● Evidence synthesis, explained
JAMAevidence for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis
Learn how the Users’ Guides, the calculators and the worksheets in JAMAevidence guide you through every stage of evidence synthesis, from the first question to the final recommendation.
The review pipeline
- Frame the question
- Register a protocol and search
- Screen and select studies
- Appraise and extract
- Synthesize the results
- Grade the certainty of evidence
- Report and apply
A systematic review is only as trustworthy as the person reading it.
Two ideas that are easy to blur
The two are linked, but they are not the same thing.
Evidence-based medicine
Systematic review
A systematic review is one of the best sources an evidence-based practitioner can use. JAMAevidence teaches both sides: how to do and read a review, and how to use it for the patient in front of you.
From question to recommendation in seven stages
Frame the question
- Name the population precisely: condition, severity, age group and setting.
- State the intervention and the comparator in enough detail to decide whether a trial qualifies.
- Choose outcomes that matter to patients, and say which one is primary.
- Decide which study designs are eligible before you search.
Register a protocol and search
- Register the protocol before screening and cite the registration number in the report.
- Search several databases and record the platform, date and full search string for each.
- Include trial registries and reference lists to find unpublished and ongoing studies.
- Plan how the search will be updated if the topic moves quickly.
Screen and select studies
- Screen independently in duplicate, and pilot the criteria first.
- Keep a log of every full-text exclusion with its reason.
- Link all reports of the same study before extracting data.
- Use screening software such as Covidence or Rayyan to manage records and decisions.
Appraise and extract
- Choose the risk-of-bias tool that matches each study design.
- Assess bias for each outcome result, not once for the whole study.
- Extract outcomes exactly as each study defined them, and note when definitions differ.
- Record funding sources and declared conflicts of interest.
Synthesize the results
- Check that studies are similar enough before pooling, then choose the effect measure and model deliberately.
- Read heterogeneity and the confidence or prediction interval before the pooled number.
- Prespecify subgroup analyses and treat unplanned ones as hypothesis-generating.
- Report absolute effects as well as relative ones, so clinicians can see the size of the benefit.
Grade the certainty of the evidence
- Rate certainty separately for each important outcome, not for the review as a whole.
- Explain every downgrade or upgrade in a footnote, so others can disagree with a specific judgment.
- Present results in a Summary of findings table with absolute effects.
- Keep certainty of evidence and strength of recommendation apart.
Report and apply
- Follow PRISMA 2020 and the extension that matches your review type.
- Include the flow diagram, the registration number and where the data can be found.
- State the limitations of the evidence and of the review process itself.
- Present absolute effects and certainty so readers can weigh benefits and harms.
Inside the book
Four chapters on systematic reviews
The Summarizing the Evidence part of Users’ Guides to the Medical Literature (3rd edition) is where review methods are taught. Here is what each chapter helps you do.
Learn the sequence of a review: question, protocol, search, selection, appraisal, extraction and synthesis.
- Use it to plan a review of your own.
- Use it to judge how someone else conducted theirs.
- The online chapter includes a discussion of the process by M. Hassan Murad.
Learn to read the output of a meta-analysis and to apply it.
- Interpret a pooled estimate and its confidence interval.
- Judge whether results are consistent across studies.
- Decide whether the findings apply to your patient.
Network meta-analysis compares several interventions at once, combining direct comparisons with indirect ones through shared comparators.
- Understand why the method is used.
- Know what assumptions it needs, such as transitivity and consistency.
- Learn to judge whether a network is believable.
Two topics that decide how much to trust a pooled result.
- Fixed-effects and random-effects models: different assumptions about whether studies estimate one true effect or a distribution of effects.
- Subgroup analysis: when a difference between subgroups is believable and when it is not.
Reading a published review
Six questions to ask of any systematic review
These questions follow the validity, results and applicability logic used throughout the Users’ Guides.
1. Did the review address a focused question?
A clear question names the population, intervention or exposure, comparator and outcomes. If you cannot state the question in one sentence, the review may be too broad to interpret.
2. Was the search comprehensive and the selection reproducible?
Look for several databases, a described search strategy, explicit eligibility criteria and two independent reviewers. A narrow search can miss studies and bias the result.
3. Were the included studies appraised for risk of bias?
The review should say how it judged bias in each study and use that judgment when interpreting the pooled result. Pooling flawed studies produces a precise but misleading answer.
4. Were the results consistent across studies?
Look at heterogeneity. If studies disagree widely, ask why before accepting one pooled number, and check whether the review explored the reasons.
5. How precise is the pooled estimate?
Read the confidence interval, not only the point estimate. A wide interval means the true effect could be much smaller or larger than the headline number.
6. Do the results apply to my patient?
Compare the studied populations, interventions and outcomes with your situation, and weigh benefits against harms and costs. Certainty ratings such as GRADE help you decide how firmly to act.
The platform
One platform, four books and a set of tools
Systematic review skills are one thread. The same platform covers the clinical side of evidence-based practice.
Users’ Guides to the Medical Literature
The Rational Clinical Examination
JAMA Guide to Statistics and Methods
Care at the Close of Life
Learning tools
- Education Guides: slide sets and PowerPoint files
- Calculators and nomograms
- Critical appraisal and information cycle worksheets
- Glossary and self-assessment quizzes
Who it is for
Four readers, four ways to use it
Review authors and researchers
Plan your methods, practice appraisal and understand the statistics before you pool.
Residents and students
Prepare journal clubs and assignments, and learn to judge a review rather than quote its abstract.
Clinicians
Decide how far to trust the reviews and guidelines that shape your practice.
Faculty and educators
Teach evidence synthesis with ready-made slides and durable links to chapters.
Study the whole pipeline with your own JAMAevidence account
How it works
- Choose JAMAevidence on the McGraw Hill Medical Access page, or pick the ALL in ONE package.
- Read the product details before you order, then complete your purchase.
- Receive a dedicated account with direct access to the platform. [Add: activation time]
Questions and answers
Frequently asked questions
What is JAMAevidence?
JAMAevidence is an online resource for teaching, learning and applying evidence-based medicine, built by McGraw Hill with the JAMA Network. It combines four textbooks with calculators, worksheets, education guides and a glossary.
Does JAMAevidence teach systematic reviews and meta-analysis?
Yes. The Summarizing the Evidence part of the Users’ Guides (3rd edition) has chapters on the process of a systematic review, understanding and applying results, network meta-analysis, and advanced topics such as fixed-effects and random-effects models.
Is JAMAevidence a tool for conducting a review?
It is a learning and decision-support resource. It teaches the methods and judgments behind a review. You would still use databases, screening and extraction workflows, and reporting standards such as PRISMA 2020 to carry one out.
What is the difference between evidence-based medicine and a systematic review?
Evidence-based medicine is a practice of making clinical decisions with the best evidence. A systematic review is a research method that summarizes studies on one question. Reviews are one of the best sources EBM practitioners use.
Which books does JAMAevidence include?
Users’ Guides to the Medical Literature (3rd edition), The Rational Clinical Examination, the JAMA Guide to Statistics and Methods and Care at the Close of Life.
What tools come with the books?
Education Guides, calculators and nomograms, critical appraisal and information cycle worksheets, a glossary of more than 900 terms and self-assessment quizzes.
Is JAMAevidence the same as JAMA Network?
No. JAMA Network publishes medical journals. JAMAevidence is a separate educational platform on evidence-based medicine.
Do I need an account?
A free MyAccess profile lets you save worksheet notes, take quizzes and return to saved content. Through AliMed you also receive a dedicated account for access.
Can I buy JAMAevidence on its own through AliMed?
Yes. JAMAevidence is available as an individual option on the AliMed McGraw Hill Medical Access page, and an ALL in ONE package is also offered.
